Reviews & Guides

Write a guide

HOW TO IDENTIFY FAKE OIL PAINTINGS & STOP WASTING MONEY

by: brushmarks100( 203Feedback score is 100 to 499) Top 5000 Reviewer
35 out of 38 people found this guide helpful.


Oil paintings, water colours, acrylics, drawings both ancient and modern are all capable of being copied.

The best way to recognise them is to learn how they are made. Our 1,300 page book on this subject complete with many colour photographs is a unique publication and a world first.

This picture hangs in my own lounge and is just under two metres long and in the book you will discover just how this type of production was made. It cost me £35 to make and I have been offered over £3,000 but, of course, if I sold it then I would be in serious trouble.But if the buyer had read the book then he wouold never have made the offer......................

BRUSHMARKS

There is now way of guaranteeing that any picture is genuine unless you have some real knowledge of the subject but you can minimize the risks to a certain valuable extent.

LET THE BUYER BEWARE. E-Bay auctions are no different from any other auctions.

Auctions are like any other market place but knowledge is strength !

There are many theoretical publications available that purport to offer help but few are written from a practical point of view and even fewer that are written by poachers turned game keepers - like our selves.

If you do make a mistake and there is no one to help you then there is one consolation and that is that if you feel that you were inadvertantly mislead without redress then you can always sell it in a local auction. There is nothing untoward about this practice in that even professionals get caught out and this procedure is accepted as being "all part of the game" - and the game is called "PASS THE PARCEL".

But here are a few tips which should help, -

  1. Obviously do be careful of vendors with no track record and try to deal only with established dealers with a good feed back record.
  2. Always look at the vendor's other pictures - particularly the backs ! If they all look similar then this could be a bad sign. Pictures are like people in that they are all mostly significantly different.
  3. Consider the price being asked ! If the painting is important then it probably deserves to be in Southeby's or another major auction house.
  4. Remember that you generally get what you pay for in this life and there are few genuine bargains.
  5. Look at the other bidders; after all it has been known for small circles of friends to help each other and it could be a bad place for strangers to do business.
  6. Spelling and grammar can be important (but not here of course). If the vendor is illiterate then it could be genuine but it may be a more insidious indication. (Unless the vendor is foreign).
  7. Check the signature. There are web sites that give this information freely. The writer has recently seen an offer at £3,000 where the picture included a signature that was obviously wrong.
  8. The most important advice that I can give in this small guide is to ask questions but try to ask obtuse rather than straight forward ones.
  9. Although, in another guide, it is stated that signatures do not appear before a certain date many artists used monograms and the use of these goes right back to the 14th century and even earlier.
  10. One vendor has been sighted offering a 17th century work of art painted on plywood which was only invented in the 19th century.
  11. Watch out for low "BUY IT NOW" item prices with high postage and insurance who will only refund the item price in the event of a refund being demanded.
  12. Beware of miniature or other small paintings where there is a multitude of obvious brush marks. In real life artists go to great trouble in avoiding this and so why are the brush marks so apparent ? Is it to trap the unwary into believing that this is a true "painting" ?
  13. Visit the art galleries and imbue yourself with as many impressions as you are able in order to gird your loins for the coming fray.
  14. Watch out for phony cracks in paintings. Cracks do appear but mostly where you do not want them and if they only appear in the corners or at the edges then be careful.
  15. Consider the condition of the canvas used. I have seen very old paintings in pristine condition which is rare outside of an art gallery. Most pictures spend their lives in pride of place over the mantlepiece in the days when smokey fire grates were common.
  16. Consider the stretchers which support the canvas. Does the wood really look old or do they look as though they have been deliberately aged ?
  17. Consider the picture frame. The Chinese are offering excellent ranges of inexpensive frames but most are readily identifiable and so have a look at a few web sites to get the feel for their designs. Beware of small triangular plywood fillets which reinforce the corners. Only the Chinese do this as part of their mass production manufacture.
  18. Consider the corners of the stretchers. Are they mitred or butt jointed ? The fillets of thin wood used to actual adjust the stretch on the canvas may have an impossible job if the corner joints are inappropriate.
  19. Look at the back of the painting and remember that dust falls and the bottom stretcher should be dirtier than the others.
  20. Ask yourself why there is any dust at all on the back ? Most people clean their valuables before offering them for sale. (But, of course, a very few do not).
  21. Does the vendor really know what he is talking about ? Does he confuse gesso with plaster or composition with wood carving or even gilt with gold leaf ?

These are only a few of the points which the unwary should heed and for further guidance I must refer you elsewhere although unfortunately I am not allowed to say exactly where but the more astute amongst you will probably realize the obvious !

 

 


Guide ID: 10000000002178841Guide created: 25/10/06 (updated 27/08/08)

 
Was this guide helpful? Report this guide

Ready to share your knowledge with others? Write a guide



Member Information

brushmarks100
brushmarks100( 203Feedback score is 100 to 499) About Me
See all guides by this member
View items for sale by this memberVisit this seller's eBay Shop
Member has an eBay ShopBRUSHMARKS OF LONDON

See member's items


About eBay | Announcements | Safety Centre | Partner Centre | VeRO Protecting IP | Policies | Feedback Forum | Site Map | Help
Copyright © 1995-2008 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the eBay User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
eBay official time