Reviews & Guides

Write a guide

I Found These Fakes on ebay

by: jughandles( 639Feedback score is 500 to 999) Top 5000 Reviewer
9 out of 9 people found this guide helpful.
Guide viewed: 170 times Tags: Studio Pottery | Troika | Fakes | Leach


This is just an occasional series of posts to point out anything that even I can spot as an obvious fake.  In pointing these out I stress that these are not about attribution errors - or even overblown descriptions - but real fakes - where an item has been altered to make it look like something else.

I am sure that the sellers of these items are not responsible for these fakes, and they may have been duped themselves at dodgy auctioneers - but all serious collectors and dealers loathe these things - and the people who make them!

Number 4 - Yet more Troika fakery

Even the seller has the good grace to admit they are not too sure about the latest piece of dodgy penmanship to masquerade as a Troika lampbase, but that doesn't stop it being offered at a £40 start price ending on 13th August.(whats with the £40 start price - if its junk its junk - if its real its worth a lot more - so start at a £1, save the ebay fees, and let the market bid it up)

Note the high gloss glaze, felt tip pen mark and almost a spelling problem - Really need to do better than that fakers!

  

Number 3 - Another Troika fake - Carn Pottery in Disguise

Here is another troika fake, but this time it is a recognisable piece of fairly innocuous Carn pottery that got the embellishment.  Its for sale ending 13th July - at a £40 start - which seems quite a lot for piece of messed about Carn.

 

The description states it is in mint condition with only a fine bit of grazing to the signed initials  - which would be where the Carn pottery mark was sandpapered off!  And really - whats with the marking - a black felt tip with a red base -  this is poor quality faking

Number 2 - A Rubbish Troika fake

Astonishingly this item sold for over £80 and had 7 bidders - obviously all people who need to pay more attention to "Cash in the Attic" or "Bargain Hunt" or wherever they get their knowledge.  A real Troika teapot this size would not look like this but would cost over £500 - so what a terrific "steal" this one was.

   

Its amazing what you can do with a felt tip pen nowadays

 

Number 1 - Bernard Leach - NOT

Another bit of dodgy felt tip pen work - fortunately so bad that it failed to attract a bidder at £20.  Possibly an interesting wee jug - but blurry photos and a description of a mysterious mark that "looks like an S with a line through it" - almost enough to convince nobody that this was a St Ives piece by the great man.

    

 

If you find something listed that looks hugely dodgy - feel free to drop me a line and I may add it on to this review for the benefit of others.  Bear in mind that calling it a fake may need some expert attribution and knowledge, so be prepared to back up your case

 

 

 

 


Guide ID: 10000000007793445Guide created: 03/07/08 (updated 31/08/08)

 
Was this guide helpful? Report this guide

Ready to share your knowledge with others? Write a guide




About eBay | Announcements | Safety Centre | Partner Centre | VeRO Protecting IP | Policies | Feedback Forum | Site Map | Help
Copyright © 1995-2008 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the eBay User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
eBay official time